The Plea of Sentience
What is our place within the world?
PART 1
the significance of being
Whoever you are, this is for you. This is not a matter of belief, but of pure being. You do not need to care about animals for this to apply to you. In fact, you don’t need to care for anything or anyone beyond yourself. Your mere existence – your sentience, your bodily instinct to live – is enough for what follows from it.
For millennia, we have asked the same questions. But the meaning of life is not handed to us. We are tiny and insignificant as soon as we zoom out a bit, drifting randomly somewhere in a universe we do not yet, and may never, fully understand. Perhaps nothing, in the grand scheme of things, matters at all. So what is it then that makes life worth living? We seem to be left to create our own meaning. But, and this is crucial, this creation is grounded in one simple thing shared across all conscious beings: sentience. We feel. We suffer. Through that, life becomes something we are not indifferent to. Experience gives weight to existence. This and nothing more is what makes anything begin to matter at all.
Our sentience, therefore, is the only thing that makes morality possible. It doesn’t construct morality for us, but it is the foundation for it. Moreover, it is why we then need morals to make life in society manageable. René Descartes famously said : “I think, therefore I am.” This may be a plausible basis for the certainty about our existence, but it is certainly not a foundation for morality, nor for what does or does not matter.
One may argue that existence is even more foundational than both thought and feeling. But existence alone is neutral – nothing of value follows from it. A thing can exist without carrying any meaning. Only the felt experience of that existence can make something good or bad, as it opens up the possibility of suffering and directs our actions for survival. For example, a rock exists, but nothing can matter to it. It has no nervous system, no neurons to process stimuli, and consequently no capacity to experience its existence in any form. It has no internal perspective. Nothing can be good or bad for it. A sentient being, however, possesses the ability to feel its existence. And that is not something unique to humans.
We may not be able to prove the existence or experience of others, but we know what it is to feel – to suffer, to resist harm. And when we see others responding to harm in similar ways, human or non-human, then we cannot dismiss it without undermining the very condition that makes our own existence matter.
When we see a dog yelping in pain or a pig squealing in fear, we recognise in them the same capacity for suffering that gives our own experience its significance. In other words, as our own experience of life is certain to us, dismissing it in others is inherently contradictory. Thus, sentience is the moral starting point. This is an idea developed by Peter Singer, who argues that the capacity to suffer is what grounds moral consideration. What matters becomes not whether a being can think, but whether it can feel. Knowledge is uncertain, but experience is undeniable. If we accept this truth, consistency requires moral consideration reaching beyond the limits of our own species to all sentient animals. Humans cannot use their intellect as a moral high ground as intellect varies among humans themselves.
What we share as conscious beings is the capacity to feel. To ignore that is not a failure of reason, but a denial of something more fundamental – our existence. Reason only comes second to the state of being. Through it, we invented language, and through language, the systems and structures that shape the world we now live in. What we take to be objective truth or morality emerges from intersubjective agreement. In this sense, we construct our truths. But these constructions do not replace the foundation upon which they are built. Therefore, these constructions cannot be used to justify what contradicts that foundation: the state of being and feeling. We cannot reason away suffering, and we cannot pick and choose where it’s worth respecting. We cannot reject real suffering simply because it is felt by those who don’t have language like us to defend themselves. If aliens were to arrive on planet earth to take from our bodies what they claimed they needed, without understanding or responding to our pleas, we would resist. We would not want our worth to be determined by their logic, their profit or their purposes.
I arrive at a principle: if the capacity to feel makes anything matter at all, morality must begin with the consideration of that capacity wherever it exists. This principle must be met with consistency, not preference shaped by human intellect.This is the premise at the core of my argument for the abolition of unnecessary infliction of suffering upon another sentient being. In this case specifically, for the abolition of animal exploitation.
where we fail to see
If we agree on the premise of sentience, why don’t we live by it? The answer requires nuance. Is it wiser to start off somewhere else? Would you consider yourself a good person? More importantly, what does that actually mean? Does it mean to defend your beliefs at all costs, or does it mean to be open to the possibility that there may be something you have not yet seen?
We don’t like being wrong about things. However, it’s okay to be wrong, it’s okay to change one’s mind, it’s okay to see things you were earlier ignorant of. This definitely doesn’t mean having no convictions or being swayed by every opposing opinion – not at all – it just means openness and willingness to learn and reconsider when there is a reason to. Too often, we approach discussion not as a way of understanding and reaching consensus, but as a way of defending. Some argue simply for the sake of being right. This is where discussion loses its purpose and stands in the way of true progress. This is because discussion with the intention of protecting our pride hinders us from reaching a collective agreement on what would be best for all of us. Instead of discussion bringing us together, it then divides us further. And so, we build walls instead of bridges. If logically the latter would be the better option, why do we act against it?
As feeling and thinking beings, we are drawn toward what affirms us, and resistant to what unsettles that. It’s easier to seek confirmation of what we already know and believe, it feels safer than to challenge it. To be wrong feels uncomfortable, so we avoid it. But it is exactly that state that allows us to grow. The expansion of knowledge and ability only works through exposure. If we accept this, and the aim is not solely to be right, but to look for the genuine good, it is important to make the following distinction of how we understand and approach the unknowing among us. We use ignorance as an accusation or an insult, yet ignorance itself is actually quite a human condition. Actually, it describes a state of unawareness: a lack of knowledge or understanding. In this sense, all of us have been ignorant, and all of us remain ignorant in some way. Nobody can know and experience everything. At times, the issue may not be the lack of knowledge, but the resistance to earnest acknowledgement.
It is important to distinguish this from indifference. Indifference is the absence of care. Ignorance is not a moral flaw in itself yet, whereas indifference is. Much of what and who we call indifferent, may just still be failing to see. I believe many people are not indifferent, but limited. They fail to grasp what is actually happening. And that, for those who do see, is difficult to witness and accept. Still, I believe the antidote to ignorance is not condemnation, but attention and even compassion. It is dialogue, discussion, grounded argumentation, and openness to engage. Not for all, but for many of us, I believe there is hope in reaching consensus. At the root of it lies the same premise: if your own existence matters to you, then the existence of others cannot be something you are indifferent to. And yet, we often fail to live by this. Not necessarily because we do not care, but because we do not fully see. Ignorance is by far not the entire story but questioning it, especially in ourselves, is where understanding can begin.
the cost of knowing
I crumble into moments of hopelessness. When all I could ever do feels small, almost pointless against this incomprehensible whole. How can we change a world for the better, if not even the very people closest to us will see as we do. Each and every one of us holds their version of truth. In competing realities, certainty itself begins to dissolve. What is familiar is mistaken for what is right.
It is uncomfortable, sometimes painful, to confront what lies beyond that which seems normal. It is easier not to question what is most intrinsic to us. Even people with the best intentions, myself included, don’t see through everything that shapes their perception. Sometimes, even when we try, we cannot find our way out. You see, the state of being unaware is not something we are aware of. Only in hindsight do we truly recognise the state we are in before. But once you do, you resist ever going back. What remains is hope: the hope to get others to see someday…
More than two thousand years ago, the ancient Greek thinker Plato, described something that still rings true today in his allegory of the cave. Imagine some guys that have spent their entire lives facing a wall. In front of them, shadows move as flat flickering images; shapes without any depth. That is all they have ever seen and known, all they can be certain of. So they take these images on the wall to be the entirety of what there is in the world. This is their world. This is the reality they understand. They learn to read the images, to name them, even to play with them. Entire meanings are built from them. But they do not know where they come from. They do not turn around because they don’t see why they should: their gaze is fixed. But since this is all they know, they do not think to search for more, ignorant of what more could be possible. For them, the world is complete. Not because it is but because it is all they have ever seen.
Imagine now, that one of them is forced to turn around. The source of the shadows, a fire behind him, is painful to see at first. It makes no sense, it contradicts everything he ever believed in. The shapes he once trusted dissolve into something unfamiliar. He stands, he walks further: out of the cave, out into the world beyond. He discovers so much more. What he once believed was only the surface of a much deeper reality. And once seen, it cannot be unseen. Why would he ever choose to go back and stare at a wall, when there is an entire world to know and explore. He wants the others to join, but they resist. They cling to what is still unquestionable reality for them. They cling to what is normal.
the illusion of familiarity
Why does the cave exist? Why do opinions vary so strongly?
People rarely begin with the question of what is true. We begin with what makes sense from where we stand. And where we stand is not neutral. It is shaped. We are formed by all of what surrounds us: by what we are taught, what we are exposed to, and the circumstances we live under – by everything. Language itself shapes our perception. It permits us to think, but also limits and directs those thoughts. The problems we do or do not face, the power we do or do not have, the conversations we are part of, the perspectives we encounter, the environment around us and more we don’t even think to process. It all shapes the way the world appears to us. Each of us exists within a paradigm, a form of framework of understanding. And that paradigm does not feel like interpretation, it feels like reality. And this is where the concept of normality begins. What is familiar becomes self-evident, repeated and unquestioned. What is always there fades into the background. We get used to it. It becomes invisible. And it is this invisibility that we come to call normal. What is normal begins to feel right. But normal is not always right. Our history is proof of that:
boundaries of concern
Throughout history, what was considered normal at another point in time very often turned out to be far from what was right. Things that now seem unimaginable, horrific even, were once just daily life, and accepted without question. But again, what we think of as normal is shaped by the structures we live within, so we must look beyond. As Karl Marx argued, history has often been driven by the struggle between those with power and those without. And it is through that struggle that any change becomes possible. Where would we be without it?People resisted the normal of their time. They challenged it. They demanded something better.
Quobna Ottobah Cuguano, also known as John Stuart, was one of them. He was an abolitionist. He himself was enslaved in Ghana and subjected to cruelty. He later gained freedom in England. He learned the language, and found the words to speak out against the injustice he and so many others suffered under the hands of those in power, giving a voice to what needed to be heard. Still, so many would not listen, and shame him instead. Whereas today, we are in disbelief of how such a system could ever be legal and considered acceptable.
Mary Wollstonecraft was another. As one of the first recognised female thinkers, she criticised the notion that moral principles could be universal, something that Immanuel Kant claims with the categorical imperative, while excluding women.
What was presented as universal was, in reality, limited by the norms of its time. So why do we think the same? Every generation so far has thought of themselves as civilised and progressive, what makes us think we’re done yet? And it is still, always and again, the activists such as Wollstonecraft and Cugoano that get ridiculed for pointing out what may be uncomfortable for many to see. The idea of women participating and being enabled to vote was met with mockery or treated as utterly absurd. And yet they were, as we know now, right all along. Step by step, the boundaries of moral concern grew. But so far, those boundaries have remained within our own species. If the aim is truly equality, and we accept that what is normal is not necessarily what is right, then let us return to the premise: if it is the capacity to experience our existence through sentience that creates moral worth, then the boundaries of our moral concern appear willfully chosen. They are shaped by our perception of things, rather than grounded in moral or rational consistency.
What if we reconsider? What were to look beyond what is normal for us at this point in time. We could call this principle of shared sentience the declaration of rights of sentient beings, including human and non-human animals. During the french revolution, the first declaration of rights was established. This was at least a start, but only the beginning. It still excluded many. Over time, we expanded them, moving closer to overall consensus – universality.
It is our duty now, to continue that progression. To undo what may seem normal but might be wrong. Just as Ottobah Cugoano and Mary Wollstonecraft did. I believe this is the abolition of our time.
PART 2
What if moral worth is not dependent on the ability to argue for oneself? And what if our claim to moral superiority is not one we can justify?
We ought to be wary of the power of our minds. It can do great things, but it can also do great damage…
terminology
Veganism is often falsely reduced to being little more than a dietary preference, a trend or personal choice. It is not. It is a way of living. It expresses the ethical position that rejects the use and commodification of animals, of other sentient beings. It seeks, as far as possible and practicable, to exclude all forms of exploitation and cruelty.
Veganism is the follow-up of the conclusion to the thesis many will agree on: animal cruelty is unethical.
Still, veganism is surrounded by a false frame of human centrality. This is important to mention because what something is called shapes what it is taken to be. And what it is taken to be shapes how it is thought of. And as we have seen, we do not easily question what is perceived as normal.
our normal
I invite you to read the following with an open mind and, if you like, an open heart. Not to abandon what you believe, but to adjust the lens through which you look – just enough to see what might cloud your perception of reality, or of what might otherwise have remained just a shadow.
We do things every day that we do not question. They do not feel like choices, they are simply given. They are normal. Rarely do we ask how they came to be so. We adopt habits, use language, brush our teeth, drive at a green light and stop at a red one. We go to work, wear certain clothes, put on make-up, use technology – and we eat animals. Many of these things are necessary to organise life in society. Some are not. Some are simply cultural. But we often mistake culture with good judgement. For example, in some societies, it is considered normal to eat dogs. In others, this feels unthinkable. But whether one eats a dog or a pig is, as horrendous and heartless as that may sound, a difference of human culture. And that is all. So what makes one acceptable and the other not? Both animals have personalities, form bonds, play, cuddle, and experience the world through their sentience. The difference is not in them, but how we humans assess them.
Our reaction to others eating dogs actually might say more about ourselves than about them. We view other cultures through our own lens, the western gaze, judging other practices by our standards of normal. Why is that? What are these cultural constructions that excuse moral inconsistency?
I don’t question nature. I question how far we have removed ourselves from it…
It is legal. Why would we question what is lawful? What is legal feels acceptable… But what if we had always thought like this? Meat is everywhere. It’s available. It’s convenient, and normalised to the point of automaticity. Meat is on menus, in supermarkets, in all countries, in homes. It is unusual if there isn’t any. Everyone seems to eat it, everyone seems to enjoy it. Everyone seems to accept it. So why should you question this, if hardly anyone else does?
We are culturally socialised to eat it. We grow up not knowing where it comes from, not really. And even as adults we remain distant from the process that turns a fellow sentient being’s entire purpose of existence into what lands on our plates for, what, like 18% of our calorie intake? We no longer see animals. And what we don’t see, what we did not do ourselves, we often don’t feel responsible for. Language, again, shapes how we think. We say “meat”, not “animal”. We label slaughter as “humane”, and take that to mean it’s okay. We reframe things to make them feel more harmless. When we walk through the meat aisle in the supermarket, we don’t see dead animals, all we see is products. We say we love animals, yet we pay for them to suffer and be killed. More in a year than the total number of humans who have ever existed. Eating animals is not only accepted, it is expected. It is deeply embedded in traditions and in culinary practices. And so, not questioning becomes a form of social conformity. Being the vegetarian or vegan in the family, or wherever, is often still an uncomfortable moment. It is often still met with mockery, or not really taken seriously. Seen as a preference, nothing more. In a world so meat-centric, we wonder what would even be left without it.
Behind the normality lies a system. A massive economic structure that depends on continued consumption. It is profitable to keep things as they are. The system creates fairy stories to keep us distracted. What we get to see are images of cows grazing on fields – as happy as ever. What if these are carefully constructed representations that conceal, careful not to reveal, the tremendous horror that goes on behind closed doors? Wouldn’t that be something we would – normally – call propaganda? Of course, this is all we know. It is easy, it is a habit. And put simply: it is yummy. But not all habits are good, not all pleasures are good. We know this from other things we may but dare not do. Since everyone is doing it, and because it is the system, we forget that every individual choice contributes to it.
Change is uncomfortable. Normal is easy, normal requires no effort. Instead, we dismiss. We avoid. We defend what we believe in already, or don’t think to question it. We build a wall to fend off confrontation. Let us shed our pride, and take a peek at what lies behind.
look reality in the eye
Humans inflict suffering that we do not even consider, in masses that we fail to comprehend with our so highly praised intelligence – yet we cannot visualise these numbers in real life, even if we try. Every year, more than 80 billion land animals are killed for food alone. That translates to 200 million every day. Thousands and thousands every second. These numbers do not include fish and other sea animals, whose deaths are counted in trillions. So many lives for a meal, a moment, a taste.
Sources such as the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) and Our World in Data, note that more than 90 percent of the animals we use come from factory farms. What happens in these institutions stays largely hidden from us because we, if we truly knew and were fully exposed to it, would not agree. Here is only a glimpse of that reality: male chicks are shredded to death shortly after birth because they are considered economically useless. Female ones are bred to grow so fast they can’t hold themselves, their own weight breaks their bones. Pigs are kept in spaces so small they cannot turn around. Their tails are cut, and their teeth get clipped without any pain relief. We hang pigs and sheep and cows upside down, slit their throats and let them bleed out. Cows are repeatedly and forcefully impregnated. We take their children and the milk they produce for them. And at the end of their miserable lives, once their productivity declines, we slaughter and eat them. Most of these animals we abuse have never even been outside, have never even seen the sky, never had the chance to be a part of their natural habitat. Fish are hauled out of the sea. Often crushed or left to suffocate. Dolphins, turtles, whales and other beautiful creatures are caught in fishing nets, often referred to as nothing but collateral damage or “bycatch”.
Animals are reduced to commodities. We eat animal bodies without a second of acknowledgment to the life that was taken for it. We wear them. We use them to test our shampoo and our vaccines, even condoms. They feel all this. They panic. They scream. They resist. But we ignore their sentience. This is not a necessity. This is cruelty. It is legal. It continues. To improve the conditions of the system, as glorious as that, and other titles such as “organic”, “humane” or “biological” may sound, is just another attempt to avoid the undeniable.
the myth of natural
It is said that eating animals is natural. That is simply what humans have always done, and will therefore always do. There have been times, and still are places, where humans, like other animals, have killed to get by. I do not question nature nor necessity. I question the time progress stopped meaning improvement. I question what we are doing now. What if we are born into systems we forget to question? What if we find it hard to imagine that things could ever be, or once were, different? If we take a step back – has the commodification of animals always been like this?
What I am referring to is, in my opinion, one of the most pressing arguments against animal exploitation. And it is not discussed nearly enough. Blinded by what feels normal, we fail to see that what we do today operates on an entirely different scale. We eat more meat, and have access to it more easily than ever before in human history. It is no longer about survival or necessity, but about industrialised commodification and systematic exploitation.
With the rise of machines, chemicals, free markets, and mass production, life – human and animal – became something that could be systemised, rationalised, and optimised. The outcome: factory farms. From cages to artificial impregnation to slaughter lines. Bodies are engineered, controlled, confined, exploited: and then sealed in plastic. To the consumer, that horror is distant, almost dystopian. These words expose reality, yet they belong to the same industries that promote our paying into the system, while the suffering they turn into food remains out of sight, and with that, out of mind.
Resigning from participation in this system feels like restriction, but it is also a realignment with our values. It is a peace offering to the world we inhabit. Because bodies that get reduced to items and sentience that gets compressed into sausages may not be so natural after all… What would it mean to be directly confronted with these processes? Or does distance make it easier to deny what is otherwise undeniable? If this feels uncomfortable, it may be because it asks us to look more closely at something we usually overlook.
And I am deeply sorry. For them.
Our Place
What I have discussed ultimately comes down to speciesism. The idea or belief that humans are more important than animals. In its essence, it resembles other forms of discrimination: a division based on differences, where one group places itself above another. Without a doubt, we are the dominant species. We have reshaped the entire world beyond the natural one we came to be in. We make tools, build weapons, and construct entire systems – factory farms – to maximise efficiency and profit. But dominance is not the same as superiority. Superiority is just something we declare. The assumption of standing above all else is not a fact, but a perspective.
Our bodies mirror both plants and animals, we have become detached from that. We breathe the air given from trees, and trees breathe ours in return. Even the gap between what we are and what animals are is smaller than we tend to presume. Biologically, we share almost all of our genes with chimpanzees. We observe many similarities in their behavior to a human’s. The difference is simply that, as humans, we reflect on our actions. We are capable of understanding what we do. We justify actions, give reasons for them, and build systems around them. We organise life through language, and through it create moral frameworks. This does not place us above non-human beings, but under accountability.
Those without language like ours cannot revolt against us, so we take silence as permission to continue. But silence is simply a difference in expression, not in existence or value. And so, exploiting animals reveals a gap in our moral consistency. If our ability to be and feel gives us moral relevance, then we must apply that beyond our own species. We already act on this principle selectively. We care about some animals: cats, dogs, even pigs, cows and chickens when we see them in the living form. We claim to love them, to preserve them. Still, we exploit them. The difference between compassion and oppression lies solely in how we perceive them.
This is not nature. It is a socially constructed hierarchy. One we have learned, and one we continue to uphold. So far removed from what we are, we have come to forget something fundamental: We are a part of nature. We are nature itself. We see earth and all that comes with it as something that should serve our existence. We must understand that we are not entitled to dominion. We are not bound to the necessity of harming animals to survive. We kill simply because we can. But we have the choice, and with choice comes responsibility. Let us start taking the responsibility that comes with the rationality we possess seriously. Because to recognise suffering and still ignore it is itself a form of cruelty.
I dream of a time where our respect extends beyond humanity to the rest of our world. We may one day hope for the same empathy in return from powers we created ourselves. I dream of a world that we see ourselves as part of, not as rulers over it. You have made it out of the cave. It may hurt. Do not go back. It is your chance to act according to your own sentience – on what you already believe in.
last words
No taste, no pleasure, no reasoning is worth the suffering we inflict on our neighbours for it. If you experience and value your own existence, to deny that same value in others is to contradict yourself. This principle allows us to dismantle what we accept as normal, and helps to reveal more clearly what matters more. This is the Plea of Sentience.
We inherit the world as it is. But if we recognise our distorted perceptions, our shared sentience and our place within nature, we must choose differently. We must choose a more compassionate future. Many hardships and power plays in this world are out of our control. This is something each and every one of us can do. And every choice counts. Change starts with what we are willing to see, and then what we are willing to refuse. Let us take each other by the hand and build the world that is already on the horizon. I would love to be a part of it.
And you?




